Hallmark
An inversion injury, swelling lateral and anterior to the malleolus, and difficulty weight-bearing. The anterior talofibular ligament is injured first and most often; the calcaneofibular ligament follows.
Tests — do these 4–7 days after the injury, not on the swollen acute ankle
- Anterior drawer at the ankle — 10–20° plantarflexion, stabilise the tibia, draw the talus anteriorly. Positive: increased anterior translation compared with the other side, especially with a soft endpoint. Sn 32–80% / Sp 80%
- Talar tilt — invert the talus with the ankle in 10–20° dorsiflexion for the calcaneofibular ligament, and in plantarflexion for the anterior talofibular. Positive: excessive gapping versus the other side. Sn 50% / Sp 88% (Hertel) — a positive is more useful than a negative
- Palpation of the ligament — Positive: focal tenderness over the specific ligament. Genuinely underrated: it localises the injury better than either stress test.
Next: grade by the presence of a firm endpoint and by how long they were unable to weight-bear, not by how dramatic the swelling looks. Re-examine at day 5 — that is when the stress tests become meaningful.